> Exactly! Needs be diagnosis by doctors NOT involved in the case. Just
> wanting to help everyone to be honest.
Steve Novella,et al, is not involved in the case and he concurs. There is only one medical diagnosis, i.e. psychogenic dystonia.
As Jan said, seeing is believing. The people with physiological
Dystonia do not appear to have the same problems as the woman in the
video does.
Of course, I am not a medical doctor, and I do not play one on Usenet.
These are just my lay observations, but they are consistent with her
doctor, and the other doctors who reviewed the video.
"Mark Probert" <mark.prob
...@gmail.com> wrote in message
> news:3f63256e-f63e-4cf1-84c8-df5e0b1aad24@p36g2000vbn.googlegroups.com...
> On Nov 4, 7:58 pm, "t" <tool...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > Ummm, I think to be honest, we need a second or third diagnosis. It would
> > seem reasonable considering the possible implications of this case. By at
> > least one pro vacer and one less than pro. Where is House when we need
> > him?
> Read the information carefully, The diagnosis was made by the doctors
> treting her, not by anyone else. The report says:
> "The admitting
> > neurologist felt that there was a strong psychogenic component to the
> > symptomology, and made a final diagnosis of weakness. "
> The admitting neurologist, the one who was seeing and believing, made
> the diagnosis.
> And, the other article I posted, from Dr. Novella, is from an academic
> neurologist who practices at Yale. Academic physicians are salaried,
> and do not make an extra dime when they see patients.
> "Mark Probert" <mark.prob...@gmail.com> wrote in message
> >news:8258b567-c765-4020-bed3-49ac37a6de48@31g2000vbf.googlegroups.com...
> > On Nov 2, 11:48 pm, Jan Drew <jdrew63...@aol.com> wrote:
> > > On Oct 23, 7:45 pm, The One True Zhen Jue <Andrew_King...@yahoo.com>
> > > wrote:
> > > > On Oct 23, 7:31 pm, "JohnSmith" <some...@microsoft.com> wrote:
> > > > > "john" <nos...@bt.com> wrote in message
> > > > >news:LcqdnWPN4sd8CErXnZ2dnUVZ8m6dnZ2d@bt.com...
> > > > > > She's been diagnosed withdystonia, an extremely rare and
> > > > > > debilitating
> > > > > > neurological disease.
> > > > > >She doesn't know what else it could be
> > > > > a common effect in dumb people.
> > > > > > She says 10 days after getting a seasonal flu shot at a Reston
> > > > > > grocery
> > > > > > store in August, and on her second wedding anniversary, she got
> > > > > > sick.
> > > > > > First, she came down with flu like symptoms, then convulsions and
> > > > > > blacking
> > > > > > out.
> > > > > sore throat? headache? NO, she barfed. not a h1n1 symptom DUMBASS
> > > > > > She believes her seasonal flu shot triggered it.
> > > > > > Desiree says, "Nothing else explains such a fast moving
> > > > > > neurological
> > > > > > damage.
> > > > > except fordystonia
> > > > > > The medical hospitals ruled out everything, CAT scans normal,
> > > > > > blood
> > > > > > normal, MRI normal. The only thing that explains it is the shot
> > > > > > caused the
> > > > > > neurologic damage."
> > > > > Not at all, this is a dumb uneducated girl talking.
> > > > > > She says it is a strange disorder where muscles work against each
> > > > > > other.
> > > > > She
> > > > > > Desiree's husband, Brendan, says, "It gets worse everyday. It's
> > > > > > heartbreaking to see."
> > > > > > Desiree says the disease is irreversible. Once she loses an
> > > > > > ability
> > > > > > it
> > > > > > doesn't come back. She says there are only three ways you can
> > > > > > getdystonia
> > > > > > as an adult and they include head trauma, drug use, and poisoning.
> > > > > > While the Centers for Disease Control cannot comment directly on
> > > > > > this
> > > > > > case, they say they have no knowledge of a link between the
> > > > > > seasonal
> > > > > > flu
> > > > > > shot anddystonia.
> > > > > WELL, there you go. no link. thanks for posting this debunking.
> > > > > I new it was horseshit! lol
> > > > It appears that while Ms Jennings sincerely believes that she is a
> > > > victim of a adverse vaccine reaction, she is much more likely
> > > > suffering from psychogenicdystonia. The facts, not her conjecture,
> > > > are what really matters. It is impossible to get the flu from the
> > > > vaccine. Also, she accepts the Johns Hopkin's diagnosis ofdystonia,
> > > > but not the fact that they refer to her case as an example of
> > > > PsychogenicDystonia.
> > > >http://www.examiner.com/x-13791-Baltimore-Disease-Prevention-Examiner...
> > > > On the October 16, 2009, Fox News show, "The O'Reilly Factor", Dr.
> > > > Leigh Vinocur from the University of Maryland Medical System offered
> > > > an alternative cause to Ms. Jennings' syndrome. Dr. Vinocur stated
> > > > that there have been no cases ofdystoniaassociated with the flu
> > > > vaccine and that neurology experts at the University of Maryland were
> > > > using Ms. Jennings' case to teach neurology residents about
> > > > psychogenicdystonia.
> > > >Dystoniais a neurological disorder where twitches and other
> > > > repetitive, involuntary reactions occur. Normally, these repetitive
> > > > actions do not let up. In the interview videos, Ms. Jennings' symptoms
> > > > subside at times. According to Dr. Vinocur, neurologists saw the video
> > > > and were convinced it was psychogenic.
> > > > Psychogenic disorders do not mean that a person is faking their
> > > > symptoms. Rather, it means that the person truly believes that the
> > > > symptoms are real. However, there is no physiological reason for the
> > > > symptoms. It truly is all in their head. Examples include phantom limb
> > > > syndrome, where a hand that has been amputated along with a limb is
> > > > felt by the person as being clinched or still being there.
> > > > Psychotherapy or some medications to treat the mental issues can help
> > > > deal with psychogenic disorders.
> > > > Another important detail in Ms. Jennings' story is that she acquired
> > > > flu from the flu vaccine. This is a scientific impossiblity. The flu
> > > > virus in the injected vaccine is dead, inactive. In the solution being
> > > > injected, the virus has no cells in which to live and reproduce.
> > > > Viruses are, by definition, obligate intracellular parasites. They
> > > > need cells to live, grow, and reproduce. There has been no recorded
> > > > case of acquired flu from the flu shot vaccine. Likewise, if true, Ms.
> > > > Jennings would be the first case ofdystoniaas a result of the flu
> > > > vaccine. Furthermore, the Food and Drug Administration did not find
> > > > anything wrong or different about the lot of vaccine used.
> > > Of course not. With their vested interests and lies.
> > > Seeing is believing.
> > Like I said, you have to know how to interpret what you are seeing.
> > And, anyway, merely seeing something does not prove causality.
> > All of you anti-vacs love to cite VAERS to prove causality, when it is
> > not designed for that. I went a-hunting and found this:
> > This VAERS report that may be Desiree Jennings:
> >http://www.examiner.com/x-13791-Baltimore-Disease-Prevention-Examiner...
> > Sore throat, nasal congestions, followed by fever, body aches, chills,
> > and headache.10/8/08 Medical records received, Dates of Service
> > 10/2-10/3/09. Diagnosis: Weakness. Pt. experienced sore throat,
> > congestion, body aches, chills, headache, fatigue and fever 3 days
> > after receiving the influenza vaccine. The fatigue continued for
> > almost 2 weeks during which the patient continued to work, but on
> > 9/12/09 she presented to the ED with generalized weakness,
> > lightheadedness and an episode of syncopy that was accompanied by
> > generalized convulsions. Admitted to the hospital from 9/12-9/14/09.
> > CK and LFT's were noted to be significantly elevated. Returned to work
> > on 9/17/09 and continued to experience nausea and syncope with all
> > over trembling and was readmitted to the hospital overnight. On 9/21
> > her PCP told her she had a positive ANA and lupus. Pt. began
> > experiencing chest pain, for which steroids were prescribed. She saw
> > an Infectious Disease MD on 9/22 and had a lumbar puncture which was
> > normal. Pt. began experiencing difficulty walking, chills, sweats,
> > tremors and vivid dreams with difficulty sleeping. She began having
> > headaches described as a ""cold spot"" on the back of her head, had
> > subsequently developed a stutter, but was able to speak clearly if she
> > whispered. Her symptoms persisted and progressed to erratic movements
> > of the toe, intermittent uncontrolled blinking, difficulty focusing,
> > uncontrolled shaking, cold feet and sharp pains in the legs. Upon this
> > admission the plan was to rule out GBS, MS, malignancy, Lyme and MG.
> > Pt. noted to have dystonia, speech dysfunction, gait dysfunction,
> > anxiety, SOB, photophobia, tinnitus in the left ear, and increase in
> > appetite, a 2 lb. weight loss. It was also noted that the symptoms
> > were worsened by warm water, especially at the knees. The admitting
> > neurologist felt that there was a strong psychogenic component to the
> > symptomology, and made a final diagnosis of weakness. 10/13/09 Medical
> > records received from dates 10/2/09-10/4/09 Presented to for eval of p
> > (REDACTED)"
> > (United States Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS), Public
> > Health Service (PHS), Centers for Disease Control (CDC) / Food and
> > Drug Administration (FDA), Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System
> > (VAERS) 1990 - last week, CDC WONDER On-line Database Accessed
> > athttp://wonder.cdc.gov/vaers.htmlonNov 4, 2009 10:20:23 AM)
> > -x-x-x-x-x-x-x
> > Cue the anti-vacs to discount this in some manner.
> > PSYCHOGENIC DYSTONIA diagnosed by the treating doctors.- Hide quoted
> > text -
> > - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
> - Show quoted text -