Go to Google Groups Home    rec.arts.sf.written
Re: REVIEW: Brasy - Ian McDonald

Martin Wisse <use...@cloggie.org>

On Sat, 5 Jan 2008 21:09:50 -0800 (PST), Pete Tillman

<Till...@toast.net> wrote:
>On Jan 5, 5:58 pm, Martin Wisse <use...@cloggie.org> wrote:
>> Brasyl
>> Ian McDonald
>> 404 pages
>> published in 2007
>> .

>> From the booklog: <http://www.cloggie.org/books/>

>Martin, thanks for the nice review. I usually like McDonald, but
>bogged down badly in BRASYL, and abandoned it.

>>Meanwhile, in historical times, in 1732, Irish Jesuit priest ...

>Yeah, that's what did me in, the dull "Heart of Darkness" pastiche. I
>might have come back, but it was a library copy, and my to-read stack
>is unusually large now, so the hell with it. YMMV.

That part had no problems for me, though, yes, the pasticheness of it
was somewhat obvious....

>BTW, I've been absent from rasfw lately because the persistent DOS
>asshole has made GG (even more) worthless -- I lost my usenet feed in
>an ISP chg, and haven't set up another. news.individual.net is still
>around, yes?

That's what I'm using. Ten euro for an account, supposedly per year,
but I have the feeling they don't check up much once you've paid the
first time...

Martin Wisse