Google Groups Home
Help | Sign in
Confessions of the New American Bible
There are currently too many topics in this group that display first. To make this topic appear first, remove this option from another topic.
There was an error processing your request. Please try again.
flag
  1 message - Collapse all
The group you are posting to is a Usenet group. Messages posted to this group will make your email address visible to anyone on the Internet.
Your reply message has not been sent.
Your post was successful
waheedm...@hotmail.com  
View profile
 More options 24 Aug 2005, 13:13
From: waheedm...@hotmail.com
Date: Wed, 24 Aug 2005 05:13:27 -0700
Local: Wed 24 Aug 2005 13:13
Subject: Confessions of the New American Bible
The introduction to this Bible includes an article entitled: How to
Read Your Bible. This article makes a lot of valuable points. I
reproduce for your edification some of the main points offered in that
introduction. Everything listed in the points below is directly
asserted in the article itself or implied therein. I have only
summarized. I did not improvise. Where I use my own words I still
represent the ideas of the authors. Often, you will notice the presence
of quotations marks. These mark off the included words as the words
actually used by the editors of the New American Bible, St. Joseph
Medium Size Edition. The article from which the points are drawn is
found on pages 17 to 35 of the introduction. Consider these points; use
them politely and wisely.

What the Scholars confess about the Bible in General
The Bible is not necessarily the most read book or the best understood
book.

The Bible was inspired by God. But "This does not mean that God
dictated His message as a businessman dictates a letter to a secretary.
God takes the author as he is and leaves him free to choose his own
means of communication."

"Some authors chose existing folk tales and even beast fables to bring
out their point."

There is a difference between INSPIRATION and REVELATION. The entire
Bible is inspiration but not the whole Bible is revelation. The authors
of the Bible were inspired to search for meaning in life and in the
events of history. The search for answers was inspired, but the answers
found were not necessary revealed by God. But some of those answers are
written in the Bible by the human authors. Some of what they wrote
clearly cannot be attributed to God. "Think of the 'holy wars' of
total destruction, fought by the Hebrews when they invaded Palestine.
The search for meaning in those wars centuries later was inspired, but
the conclusions which attributed all those atrocities to the command of
God were imperfect and provisional."

An example of such atrocities is in Judges1:1-18. Read it for yourself.

The Bible is a collection of many books of different kinds. "A major
disadvantage is that these books are not put together systematically as
the books of a modern library."

"Edifying interpretation of events" is "often intermingled" with
history.

"The Bible is God's word and man's word. One must understand
man's word first in order to understand the word of God."

The Bible contains "Beast Fables." Examples: Genesis; Numbers 22,
22-35.

Speeches of persons in the Bible are not necessarily what the persons
said. "It is the inspired author who wants to state something by
putting these words into the mouth of a person with authority."

The book known as Acts of the Apostles in the Bible often puts words
into the mouths of its characters.

The description of the heavens and the earth in Genesis, chapter 1, is
not necessarily a true description. That description is conditioned by
the time and culture in which it was written. "Do not be shocked about
this!"

"The sacred writers attribute quite a number of human characteristics
to God." This too is "conditioned by time and culture."

The Psalms are a collection of poems full of feeling. Psalm 137, verses
8 and 9 pronounces a blessing on one who grabs a Babylonian baby and
dashes it against a rock. In this psalm "The feeling, the thought, the
total poem is inspired (guided) by God, though it is not necessarily
revealed truth!" But this is not the only Psalm which is not
necessarily revealed truth. To find out for yourself, "Read some
psalms!"

What the scholars confess about the Gospels in particular
"What did the authors of the Gospels do? In the congregations, mainly
in the cities around the Mediterranean, they found scores of narratives
about Jesus, the beloved Founder of the Christian faith. The writers
took those narratives and frequently even remolded and refashioned them
to bring out the lesson they wanted to teach."

Therefore the four Gospels are not really biographies of Jesus. They
are "digests of Christian teaching concerning the risen Lord Jesus."

"A remarkable fact is that for a long time Christians misunderstood"
this truth about the Gospels.

The genealogy of Jesus in Matthew's Gospel chapter 1, verses 1-17, is
not an absolutely true genealogy. First, Matthew took it perhaps from
the family of Joseph. Second, "the sacred writer refashioned this
document to a list of three times fourteen ancestors."

"Reading the Gospels, one should distinguish historical facts from
theological elaboration."

The Gospels often represent Jesus in controversy and conversation. "One
may ask: Was Jesus involved in these conversations? Did He answer
exactly as related in the Bible? It is not certain."

There may be some true events and "controversies which supplied the
background materials for the conflict stories of the Gospels. But as
these accounts now stand, they are literary forms used by the Gospel
writers in their catechisms to bring out what they had to tell the
opponents of early Christianity."

Matthew tells us that baby Jesus was taken to Egypt. This is not
necessarily true. But since Israel had been in Egypt, and since Israel
was God's chosen one, Matthew placed Jesus in Egypt to convince his
readers that Jesus was the real Israel. "This is a strange literary
device, but the ancient writers loved to work with this kind of
figurative speech."

"It is difficult to know whether the words or sayings attributed to
[Jesus] are written exactly as He spoke them."

"True, the Gospels are based on sound historical facts as related by
eye-witnesses, but both deeds and words of Jesus are offered to us in
the framework or theological interpretation."

Did Jesus say the things which the Gospels report? "The Church was so
firmly convinced that the risen Lord who is the Jesus of history lived
in her, and taught through her, that she expressed her teaching in the
form of Jesus' sayings." The words are not Jesus but from the Church.

"Can we discover at least some words of Jesus that have escaped such
elaboration? Bible scholars point to the very short sayings of Jesus,
as for example those put together by Matthew in chapter 5, 1-12"

The Sermon on the Mount in Matthew, chapters 5 to 7, was delivered by
Jesus while he was on a mount - or was he? Matthew only represented
the matter such in order to show that Jesus was like Moses who received
the law on Mount Sinai. Jesus was not really on a mountain. This is
only a figurative device used by Matthew.

"Walk into a modern library, you will find all the books neatly
arranged under fiction and non-fiction. It is not that simple in the
library called the Bible. How does one know whether one deals with
history or some form of figurative speech?" To begin with you should
always be disposed to follow the teaching authority of the Church."

"The signature of a bishop in your Bible assures you that opinions,
expressed in footnotes and introductions, reflect what is generally
accepted as sound doctrine in the Catholic tradition."

"Knowing that early Christians mistakenly expected Christ's second
coming during their own lifetime, helps you to understand 1 and 2
Thessalonians." The first of these two books in the Bible is written
under the said mistaken expectation.

"The Hebrews [who wrote the Bible] were restless searchers for meaning
in our human condition. Reading their inspired literature should
challenge you to go on with a faithful search for meaning in your own
situation."

There you have it folks. A collection of confessions of the scholars
who edited the New American Bible. The words within quotation marks are
their own. All the ideas are their own. Some of the said ideas they
have explicitly stated; others they clearly imply. Words within square
brackets were inserted where necessary to make the points clear. Use
these points to help convince Catholics.

The title page of this Bible shows that the book is "authorized by the
Board of Trustees of the Confraternity of Christian Doctrine" and
"approved by the Administrative Committee/Board of the National
Conference of Catholic Bishops" and the "United States Catholic
Conference." It is published by the Catholic Book Publishing Co., New
York, 1986. The Bible contains all the necessary Catholic
certification: the Nihil Obstat, and the Imprimatur from the Archbishop
of Washington. And, oh, yes! A letter from the Vatican, including the
signature of the Pope, appears in the preface to guarantee the
reliability of this Bible for Catholics.

Protestants and others may not be convinced by the confessions. They
may object that these are not their own scholars. Yet many Protestant
scholars have reached the very same conclusions. But that is the
subject for another article. Notice, however, that you can always argue
that the points above are admitted by friends of the Bible. Even one
who does not recognise the authority of Catholic Bishops will have to
admit that they are nevertheless friends of the Bible. Their testimony
above cannot be discounted so easily.

Muslim callers to Allah will find it advantageous to obtain a copy of
the said Bible and use it wisely. Always present your points with
respect and love. Do not seek to defeat the other person with clever
arguments, but seek to win him over with courtesy and persuasive
speech.


    Reply to author    Forward  
You must Sign in before you can post messages.
To post a message, you must first join this group.
Please update your nickname on the subscription settings page before posting.
You do not have the permission required to post.
End of messages
« Back to Discussions « Newer topic     Older topic »

Create a group - Google Groups - Google Home - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy
©2008 Google